Can Money Buy Happiness?

January 19, 2012

clipboardI just finished reading “The Behavior Gap: Simple Ways to Stop Doing Dumb Things with Money,” an excellent and easy-to-read book that preaches a lot of common sense about finances — something I often lack. (You know: Penny-wise and pound-foolish.)

The book doesn’t provide any hardcore financial advice; instead, it offers important reminders about money and life. And smart explanations to questions such as, “What’s the connection between happiness and money?” Author Carl Richards explains:

First, money can buy happiness — up to a point. You need some money to be happy, but once the basics are covered the link fades quickly.

Second, experiences matter more than objects. Remember the thrill of finally getting the shiny new toy? At some point, it stopped being new and shiny. The same doesn’t apply to that amazing trip you took with your family. The trip may last for only a few days, but the memories you create will bring you greater happiness throughout your life than the gadget you picked up at the store last week.

Third, happiness sneaks up on you when you let it. We may have an inalienable right to pursue happiness, but there’s no guarantee that we’ll actually capture it. Maybe we’ve let ourselves get so caught up in the pursuit that we’re missing the point….

Maybe happiness comes easiest when we are so busy working, taking care of kids, shoveling snow, or cleaning the house that we forget to look for it.

Richards’s words seem consistent with those of Gretchen Rubin, who wrote in “The Happiness Project” book that money can help buy happiness. “Whether rich or poor, people make choices about how they spend money, and those choices can boost happiness or undermine it,” she said.

So, my takeaway from these authors is that there is indeed a connection between money and happiness, but that they don’t necessarily rise and fall in-sync. And that how we choose to spend our money, not simply having money, is important to our happiness.

Also: I’ve learned recently that spending money can make me either happy or unhappy — and that my reaction usually has little relationship to the price of my purchase. For example, I’m very happy that I spent $750 on my iPad because I use it every day for work and pleasure; but I’m unhappy that I spent $15 on a book about learning to play the piano — because I’ve never opened it.

What’s your relationship between money and happiness?

The Behavior Gap: Simple Ways to Stop Doing Dumb Things with Money
  • Leschreiber

    Funny you should post this today. My husband and I were having this same discussion yesterday, and I think our consensus was that though it does take a certain amount of money to be able to pursue doing the things that make you happy, being happy is more about the actual experiences. It does take money to indulge in hobbies and traveling and those sorts of activities that can bring about happiness. But it is most definitely, at least for us, those activities that bring us joy. I guess the trick is finding activities that don’t necessarily cost a fortune!

  • Melanie

    I’m still trying to figure out how you completed Jobs’ book and still had time to read this one and blog.  Not the wisdom you were seeking…

    • http://www.BettermentBlog.com Doug Isenberg

      Melanie: Note that I called The Behavior Gap an “easy-to-read book”!

  • http://www.facebook.com/samexic Sheryl Mexic

    It definitely takes money to maintain my lifestyle and I’d be unhappy if I couldn’t maintain it.

  • http://www.atlantagreenmom.com/ Atlanta Green Mom

    I think money helps to a certain point, but once your basic needs are met then no, it can’t buy happiness.  His words are very true in that the everyday mundane may seem just that at the time, but once those moments have passed you may realize those were the happiest.

  • Leslie

    I do not feel that having money makes one happier, but it certainly can enhance one’s life and make things easier along the way.  I feel good when I can take some money and give it to someone else who is in need of it to have the basic necessities in life.  If someone feels good about how they are choosing to use and or spend their money, they may feel a sense of happiness.

  • David Geller

    I believe money can buy happiness, but not in the way one would expect.  It is easy to use money to purchase pleasure whether it is a great meal, a ticket to wonderful concert, or a new convertible.  Pleasure, however, is different from happiness.  Pleasure is all about your senses.  Happiness is built on the foundation of a stable lifestyle, and is then all about the quality of your most important relationships, your ability to be fully engaged in a high challenge and high skill activity, and your opportunities to make a differenece in the lives of others.  We can use money to improve all of those happniess producing areas of our life, but sometimes it does take a little creativity.  David Geller

    • http://www.BettermentBlog.com Doug Isenberg

      Thanks, David, I know you’ve got a book of your own coming out that touches on this very topic, so we should all be looking forward to reading more of your wisdom.

Previous post:

Next post: